Log in to check your private messages 
Username: Password:   
  Reformed Theology Institute
  RTI is a ministry for Reformed theology, worship, education, training, and discussion.
Index  FAQ  Search  Memberlist  Usergroups  Profile Scroll to Bottom  RTI Portal New Posts Since Last Visit
Recent Posts    
    Join! (free)   
 

Log in
   Username:
   Password:
   Log me on automatically each visit
  

Welcome
Guest
RTI Randomata

Recent Topics
Sola Scriptura and Solo Scriptura
A simple Criticism of Anslem's Onotological Argument
Well meant offer, denial of Irresistible Grace?
Irresistible Grace Not Reformed Doctrine?
Chapter 11: Including Non-Christians in Christian Worship...
Does 2 Peter 2:1 Deny Effectual Atonement?
A "study" with a Jehovah's Witness
Is there such thing as a Christian Nation?
"Guilt Trips": Not An Enjoyable Journey
Why do Christians still sin if they have been regenerated...
YouTube for Puritan Lovers have you seen it ?
Is God Violent?
Seventh Day Adventist's a cult?
Lyncx9 - Greek Trans & Exegesis Help for John 3:1 - 21
Dale - Greetings from New Orleans
An Argument for God's Existence as Properly Basic
Linking Posts to Facebook and other Websites
Suggestion: Numbered Posts.
Jams
Please pray.....


World Time
Los Angeles, CA
New York City, NY
London, U.K.
Moscow, Russia
Beijing, China
Sydney, Australia

RTI Topical Categories
Apologetics
Biblical Studies
Reformed Doctrine
Reformed History
Walk of Faith
Membership Central
Debates
Compliments, Suggestions, Complaints
RTI Training
Main Forum Page

TNARS Course Topics
Fruit of the Holy Spirit and Regeneration is Faith?
New D.Min. concentration in Puritan Studies
Cheung's Ministry of the Word
Course Textbooks
Inerrancy
TNARS Academic Standards
Rigor of the THE100 Course
Nearing the completion of the Preaching course
Purpose of the TNARS Forums
Cheung's Sermon on the Mount

Random Gallery Image

 
Jump to:  
Post new topic   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.    Reformed Theology Institute Forum Index » Perseverance of the Saints » Arminians: Terrorists of the Weary Soul
Author Message
Presbyterian Deacon

Admin
Admin
User Online:


Joined: 03 Jan 2009
Posts: 1160
Rep Level: 5
Rep Points: 64
Rep Hits: 14


Location: Vernon, CT

Rep This Post
PostPosted: Tue Mar 03, 2009 5:14 pm

Post Number: 3307
Reply with quote Report

The following except is taken from Thomas Brook's Heaven On Earth, (First Published 1654).  

Thomas Brooks wrote:
Arminians are not ashamed to say, that God may crown a man one hour, and uncrown him in the next; they blush not to say that a man may be happy and miserable, under love and under wrath, an heir of heaven and a firebrand of hell, a child of light and a child of darkness—and all in an hour. Oh what miserable comforters are these! What is this but to torment the weary soul? to dispirit the wounded spirit, and to make them most sad whom God would have most glad? Ah! how sad is it for men to affirm, that wounded spirits may know "that the Sun of righteousness has healing in his wings," Mal 4:2; but they cannot be assured that they shall be healed. The hungry soul may know that there is bread enough in his Father's house—but cannot know that he shall taste of that bread, Luke 15:17. The naked soul may know that Christ has robes of righteousness to cover all spots, sores, defects, and deformities of it—but may not presume to know that Christ will put these royal robes upon it, Rev 3:18. The impoverished soul may know that there be unsearchable riches in Christ—but cannot be assured that ever it shall partake of those riches, Eph 3:8. All that these men allow poor souls, is guesses and conjectures that it may be well with them. They will not allow souls to say with Thomas, "My Lord, and my God," John 20:18; nor with Job to say, "My Redeemer lives," Job 19:25; nor with the church, "I am my beloved's, and his desire is towards me," Song 7:10. And so they leave souls in a cloudy, questioning, doubting, hovering condition, hanging, like Mahomet's tomb at Mecca, between two loadstones; or like Erasmus, as the papists paint him, hanging between heaven and hell. They make the poor soul a terror to itself.

What more uncomfortable doctrine than this? What more soul-disquieting, and soul-unsettling doctrine than this? You are this moment in a state of spiritual life—you may the next moment be in a state of spiritual death; you are now gracious—you may the next hour be graceless; you are now in the promised land—yet you may die in the wilderness; you are today a habitation for God—you may tomorrow be a synagogue of Satan; you have today received the white stone of absolution—you may tomorrow receive the black stone of condemnation; you are now in your Savior's arms—you may tomorrow be in Satan's paws; you are now Christ's freeman—you may tomorrow be Satan's bondman; you are now a vessel of honor—you may suddenly become a vessel of wrath; you are now greatly beloved, you may soon be as greatly loathed; this day your name is fairly written in the book of life—tomorrow the book may be crossed out, and your name blotted out forever. This is the Arminians' doctrine, and if this be not to keep souls in a doubting and trembling, and shivering condition, what is it?


The Calvinist flower is TULIP, this quote shows why the Arminian flower is the Daisy.

"He loves me, He loves me not, He loves me, He loves me not..." Shocked
_________________
Sterling A. Harmon, Jr.
Deacon
Presbyterian Church of Coventry (PCA)

Reformed Theology Institute
Owner/Admin

"No learning is commendable which is not dipped in the love of God." --John Calvin

"A dog barks when his master is attacked. I would be a coward if I saw that God's truth is attacked and yet would remain silent." --John Calvin
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Leslie

Sustaining Member
Sustaining Member
User Online:


Joined: 30 Dec 2008
Posts: 118
Rep Level: 4
Rep Points: 19
Rep Hits: 5




Rep This Post
PostPosted: Tue Mar 03, 2009 9:38 pm

Post Number: 3316
Reply with quote Report

This is nicely stated.

The Calvinist position is not all that comforting and secure, however, since it just puts the question one step back: "Was I TRULY converted in the first place?"

Jonathan Edwards, in particular, troubles me, since he maintains that one must love God for His excellencies, not for what He does for us. True, that is the ideal, but is there then no grace for those who love God for less noble reasons? Even the psalmist said, "I love the Lord because He hears my cry and my supplication."
_________________
Leslie aka Mary
Kale Heywott Church
Soddo-Wolaitta, Ethiopia
View user's profile Send private message
elnwood

Continuing Member
Continuing Member
User Online:


Joined: 26 Dec 2008
Posts: 54
Rep Level: 1
Rep Points: 1
Rep Hits: 2


Location: San Diego, CA

Rep This Post
PostPosted: Tue Mar 03, 2009 11:41 pm

Post Number: 3320
Reply with quote Report

Arminians tell me that they are secure in their salvation if they demonstrate fruits of faith and repentance, and it's only through complete denial where salvation is lost.  I know, I think it's deeply flawed, but it's usually not like the Catholic doctrine where if they commit a major sin, they have to confess to a priest, or else it won't be forgiven of them.

In that sense, Arminians have assurance of their salvation the same way Calvinists have of their salvation -- through the fruits of salvation.

I think what is far more dangerous are those who believe that salvation cannot be lost, but think that a person can fall away or not even show fruits of repentance, yet they are saved because they "believed" once.  That is false assurance, and much more insidious than straight out Arminianism.

I think Arminianism is in error, but I generally don't find those kinds of expositions (also, the daisy analogy, and the "Arminian prayer") edifying.  It inevitably leans towards mocking the theological positions of fellow believers in Christ and putting words in their mouths that they would not say.  If we are to address it, shouldn't we address them with compassion as fellow joint heirs in Christ deserve?  Would we approve of Arminians mocking us among themselves about how we have no assurance orf our salvation because can't know if we are elect?  Or that our God ignores our desires and simply controls us like puppets?
View user's profile Send private message
Ask Mr. Religion

Moderator
Moderator
User Online:


Joined: 28 Jul 2008
Posts: 1487
Rep Level: 5
Rep Points: 84
Rep Hits: 18


Location: Chandler, AZ

Rep This Post
PostPosted: Wed Mar 04, 2009 12:21 am

Post Number: 3324
Reply with quote Report

elnwood wrote:
I think Arminianism is in error, but I generally don't find those kinds of expositions (also, the daisy analogy, and the "Arminian prayer") edifying.  It inevitably leans towards mocking the theological positions of fellow believers in Christ and putting words in their mouths that they would not say.  If we are to address it, shouldn't we address them with compassion as fellow joint heirs in Christ deserve?  Would we approve of Arminians mocking us among themselves about how we have no assurance orf our salvation because can't know if we are elect?  Or that our God ignores our desires and simply controls us like puppets?

Of course you are correct, elnwood. I don't think the quoted piece above is mocking in its tone. It is a polemic against Arminianism. Now with respect to the daisy flower, we all know as a bit of humor poking fun at Arminians and probably belongs in the Fellowship forum in a thread related to religious humor. You should hear some of my jokes related to Calvinism!  Laughing

AMR
_________________


TNARS Faculty Mentor
                           Woe is me! for I am undone; because I am a man of unclean lips...



Last edited by Ask Mr. Religion on Fri Mar 06, 2009 11:24 pm; edited 1 time in total
MSN Messenger
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Rhonda

Sustaining Member
Sustaining Member
User Online:


Joined: 03 Feb 2009
Posts: 136
Rep Level: 4
Rep Points: 7
Rep Hits: 2


Location: Australia

Rep This Post
PostPosted: Fri Mar 06, 2009 11:13 pm

Post Number: 3374
Reply with quote Report

Amen, AMR.

For years as a Christian I had never heard the terms "Arminianism" or "Calvinism" I just knew that Jesus saved me from myself. As I read my Bible more and more I learnt about original sin and the wrath of God but  my experience was always based on His ability and not mine. Pray
_________________
Rhonda
MSN Messenger
View user's profile Send private message
tartanarmy

Continuing Member
Continuing Member
User Online:


Joined: 09 Jan 2009
Posts: 62
Rep Level: 3
Rep Points: 5
Rep Hits: 2


Location: Central Coast NSW Australia

Rep This Post
PostPosted: Thu Mar 12, 2009 1:43 am

Post Number: 3426
Reply with quote Report

Interesting thread, and funny too.

But seriously. Would Spurgeon be charged with being mean for his many harsh comments about Arminianism, and he is well known for being fairly mild!

Don't get me started upon by quoting Owen, Gill, Calvin, Luther, Toplady, Knox, Turretin, Bunyan and a whole host of others.

Then there was this comment,
Quote:
In that sense, Arminians have assurance of their salvation the same way Calvinists have of their salvation -- through the fruits of salvation.


Not so. As a Calvinist, I take assurance upon the abilities of God to keep me in the faith and to believe that He who has begun a good work shall complete it.
I would despair if my focus was upon the subjective opinion of my fruits. No thank you.
And whilst others are judging me by my fruits, I will still cling to Christ and His righteousness.

We need to get back to the heart attitude of men like Bunyan who preached as a dying man to dying men.

The older I get, and the more I think I am learning something, the more I feel my own corruption and hardly know anything.

Mark
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Presbyterian Deacon

Admin
Admin
User Online:


Joined: 03 Jan 2009
Posts: 1160
Rep Level: 5
Rep Points: 64
Rep Hits: 14


Location: Vernon, CT

Rep This Post
PostPosted: Thu Mar 12, 2009 3:32 am

Post Number: 3429
Reply with quote Report

Amen!
_________________
Sterling A. Harmon, Jr.
Deacon
Presbyterian Church of Coventry (PCA)

Reformed Theology Institute
Owner/Admin

"No learning is commendable which is not dipped in the love of God." --John Calvin

"A dog barks when his master is attacked. I would be a coward if I saw that God's truth is attacked and yet would remain silent." --John Calvin
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
JM

Newbie
Newbie
User Online:


Joined: 17 Dec 2009
Posts: 35
Rep Level: 3
Rep Points: 5
Rep Hits: 2




Rep This Post
PostPosted: Mon Dec 21, 2009 10:10 am

Post Number: 6814
Reply with quote Report

I have to add that quote to my blog, I don't want to lose it...thank you.
_________________
JM
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.    Reformed Theology Institute Forum Index » Perseverance of the Saints


 
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
Interesting RTI Poll

Poll Link

Who is "the seed" of the woman mentioned in Genesis 3:15
Abel 0
Jesus Christ 17
All mankind in general 5
Total Votes : 22


Popular Topics
A List of Questions Reformed Folk Should Have An Answer To
The Lamb's Book of Life
Why were you chosen?
Participation in Lent?
Lyncx9 - Greek Trans & Exegesis Help for John 3:1 - 21
Rapture biblical or not?
Does Supralapsarianism guarantee becoming Hyper-Calvinist?
A "study" with a Jehovah's Witness
Why do Christians still sin if they have been regenerated...
Natural disasters - Are they God's judgment?
Exclusive Psalmody...
Rationale for Scholarly Reformed Hermeneutics
How does exegesis and hermeneutics relate to theology?
beegirl4 - Hello!
Facinating discussion with Rev. Matt Slick of CARM.ORG
Covenant Between the Father and the Son
Chapter 11: Including Non-Christians in Christian Worship...
A few words about the impossibility of Evolution...
Anybody taught an Adult Sunday School Class on Cov Theo?
The Modern Vs. Biblical Gospel

Main Menu
Home Page
Forums
How-To FAQs
Membership Central
Private Messages
Photo Gallery
Smilies
Bible Encyclopedia
Bible Tool

Items of Interest
Adopt a Smiley $$ Campaign
About RTI

RTI Course Topics
Incrementalist's Guide to the Basics of My Teaching NT Greek
All Things Are Better In Koine
New Forums Created
Testing Biblical Fonts
REL 300: Conformation to the Image of Christ
REL 125 Assignment 1 Responses (Nature of Evil)
REL 125 Introduction and Assignments
RTI Education Policies and Practices
RTI Courses

Top Posters
Ask Mr. Religion 1487
Presbyterian Deacon 1160
Lyncx9 608
bodhisattva 456
J&R 312
freshmao 248
J.D.Longmire 243
Lon 222
mossy 208
mmstroud 203
SolaGrazia 194
student ad x 137
Rhonda 136
yvieraebrae 130
Gord 121

 
 

RTI Users Online
Name Time Posts
bodhisattva 18 Mar 13:06 456
Lyncx9 18 Mar 13:38 608
Presbyterian Deacon 18 Mar 13:57 1160
SolaGrazia 18 Mar 13:55 194
yvieraebrae 18 Mar 13:54 130

Back to top



Bookmark and Share

phpBB skin developed by: John Olson
Powered by
phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group

Your donation supports the RTI ministry to keep this site free for all Members! Proverbs 11:24-25


ip-location

Optional full banner

Welcome To RTI "Guest"! Enjoy Your Stay!