Log in to check your private messages 
Username: Password:   
  Reformed Theology Institute
  RTI is a ministry for Reformed theology, worship, education, training, and discussion.
Index  FAQ  Search  Memberlist  Usergroups  Profile Scroll to Bottom  RTI Portal New Posts Since Last Visit
Recent Posts    
    Join! (free)   
 

Log in
   Username:
   Password:
   Log me on automatically each visit
  

Welcome
Guest
RTI Randomata

Recent Topics
Am I the only one?
Rant about Worship Songs
Happy Belated Birthday Decalogue and jd. morrison
Fasting
Lordship Salvation
Please pray for my dog...
Forthcoming Study Bible Releases
My Arminian Bible Study Group
Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod
Quotations
Hapax Legomenon
Apologetics Outline of Study
JAMS II
Can you see God?
Prayer for Navigator!
THE TOTAL AND EXCLUSIVE CLAIM OF Christ
Upcoming EPS Meeting
Please Pray for Bli
Five Dollar Friday's at Ligonier Ministries
Ordination


World Time
Los Angeles, CA
New York City, NY
London, U.K.
Moscow, Russia
Beijing, China
Sydney, Australia

RTI Topical Categories
Apologetics
Biblical Studies
Reformed Doctrine
Reformed History
Walk of Faith
Membership Central
Debates
Compliments, Suggestions, Complaints
RTI Training
Main Forum Page

TNARS Course Topics
Purpose of the TNARS Forums
Writing Papers
Fruit of the Holy Spirit and Regeneration is Faith?
New D.Min. concentration in Puritan Studies
Cheung's Ministry of the Word
Course Textbooks
Inerrancy
TNARS Academic Standards
Rigor of the THE100 Course
Nearing the completion of the Preaching course
Cheung's Sermon on the Mount

 
Jump to:  
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Reformed Theology Institute Forum Index » Cults, Apostasies, Heresies, Heterodoxies » Church of Christ a false religion? Page Previous  1, 2
Author Message
Please Register and Login to this forum to stop seeing this advertising.








Rep This Post
Posted:

Post Number:
Report

Samuel

Newbie
Newbie
User Online:


Joined: 16 Jun 2009
Posts: 10
Rep Level: 1
Rep Points: 1
Rep Hits: 2


Location: Asheville NC

Rep This Post
PostPosted: Sun Jun 28, 2009 11:51 am

Post Number: 5510
Reply with quote Report

Rhonda.

          I visited your Churches web-site. It appears their statements of beliefs to be very vague, and to me somewhat evasive.

They are members of the World Council Of Churches, an ecumenical Church movement. And from what I can tell, hold a very Liberal and Emergent view of Christianity.

Its one of those web-sites that says nothing specifically, and I find usually there is a good reason, when you ever dig deep enough.

Take care ...... Samuel
_________________
Samuel Owen.
http://www.our.homewithgod.com/biblepaths/
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
Rhonda

Sustaining Member
Sustaining Member
User Online:


Joined: 03 Feb 2009
Posts: 159
Rep Level: 4
Rep Points: 7
Rep Hits: 2


Location: Australia

Rep This Post
PostPosted: Mon Jun 29, 2009 2:44 am

Post Number: 5513
Reply with quote Report

Hello Samuel,

Thank you for your care, I appreciate it and it was on your website that I first found the listing for the Church of Christ under 'cults and religions'.
I confess to complete ignorance of the significance of the World Council of Churches and the terminology of 'ecumenical'. I do not come from a reformed background and indeed to this day have never laid eyes on a reformed church. In my country they are scarce as hens' teeth. This is why I am a member here at RTI and read and listen to as many good reformed teachers as I can. As I have stated in a previous post, coming out of a neo-pentecostal church, the Church of Christ that I attend is far more biblical and I would need a very good reason to leave. I would need to hear heresy being preached over the pulpit which I have not heard yet. I do not wish to become a church hopper nor do I wish to remain at home out of fellowship altogether and serving no one. I do believe that God's elect are in this church and I have already met another reformed brother who worships here. The website is only meant to give an overview but as Cam has pointed out it has more on it than many other churches take the time to put. I wil pray for the Holy Spirit's guidance and the gift of discernment as I listen.

Blessings,
_________________
Rhonda
MSN Messenger
View user's profile Send private message
Lyncx9

Invested Member
Invested Member
User Online:


Joined: 02 Aug 2008
Posts: 681
Rep Level: 4
Rep Points: 72
Rep Hits: 17




Rep This Post
PostPosted: Mon Jun 29, 2009 3:55 am

Post Number: 5514
Reply with quote Report

Rhonda, Presbyterian Deacon, freshmao and Samuel:

I respond to clarify what seems to me to be a misunderstanding that cannot be left unresolved.  Rhonda:  Presbyterian Deacon and freshmao have both given you excellent information and wise guidance based on accurate, valid and well researched information.

However, Samuel, are you not perhaps a bit mistaken?  Have you not, in fact, confused the Church of Christ with the United Church of Christ (which used to be essentially the Congregational Church)?  At least, made that confusion in your posting here?  The Church of Christ, priding itself as as the "Restoration Church", would never join the World Council of Churches as the United Church of Christ has done.  The Church of Christ could never be one espoused of "Liberal" or "Emergent" views, whereas that would be characteristic of the United Church of Christ.

Samuel, please check your sources carefully on this and repost in this matter so that Rhonda and the Forum will not be confused by your advice.

In Christ

Lyncx
_________________
Lynx
View user's profile Send private message
Presbyterian Deacon

Admin
Admin
User Online:


Joined: 03 Jan 2009
Posts: 1587
Rep Level: 5
Rep Points: 69
Rep Hits: 15


Location: Vernon, CT

Rep This Post
PostPosted: Mon Jun 29, 2009 5:58 am

Post Number: 5515
Reply with quote Report

Samuel wrote:
They are members of the World Council Of Churches, an ecumenical Church movement....


The Campbell/Stone Movement is "father" to various groups historically.

From what I can tell, "The Church of Christ" is not part of the WCC. However, one of the other groups, "The Christian Church" (also called "The Disciples of Christ") is, and I think, Samuel, that you are mistaken to try to lump all the groups which are historically connected to Alexander and Thomas Campbell into the same category. It would be like saying all Baptists are liberal, based upon an observation of the American Baptist Church (denomination). Stereo-types like these just don't help discussion!

Of the Disciples of Christ group however, it may be said:

The Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) is a Mainline Protestant denomination in North America. It is often referred to as "The Christian Church," "The Disciples of Christ," or more simply as "The Disciples." It has made contributions to worldwide Christianity through the evangelistic work of its missionary societies and through its participation in the ecumenical dialogue of the 20th century. The Christian Church was a charter participant in the formation of both the World Council of Churches and the Federal Council of Churches (now the National Council of Churches), and it continues to be engaged in ecumenical conversations.

Rhonda's group IS NOT the group to which Samuel refers. Though officially recognized as distinct movements from 1906, the actual separation of the Churches of Christ from the Christian Churches had already been taking place gradually for decades.
_________________
Sterling A. Harmon, Jr.
Deacon
Presbyterian Church of Coventry (PCA)

Reformed Theology Institute
Owner/Admin




"No learning is commendable which is not dipped in the love of God." --John Calvin

"A dog barks when his master is attacked. I would be a coward if I saw that God's truth is attacked and yet would remain silent." --John Calvin
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Samuel

Newbie
Newbie
User Online:


Joined: 16 Jun 2009
Posts: 10
Rep Level: 1
Rep Points: 1
Rep Hits: 2


Location: Asheville NC

Rep This Post
PostPosted: Mon Jun 29, 2009 8:41 am

Post Number: 5516
Reply with quote Report

The information about the World Council Of Churches, came from the web. I did a search on the Churches of Christ Australia, and it lumped all of them into belonging to the World Council Of Churches.

If the one Rhonda attends does not, it must be totally independent of the other Churches of Christ in Australia. And the Liberal and Emergent statement was mine, this Church being far and away more so liberal, than their counterparts here in the states.

Or maybe we could just call them progressive.

I am not trying to be confusing, I just reported on the facts as I found them. If there is any error, it is in the reports my information came from. The observations on the liberality, of course are my own. You can take that with a grain of salt. Smile
_________________
Samuel Owen.
http://www.our.homewithgod.com/biblepaths/
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
Rhonda

Sustaining Member
Sustaining Member
User Online:


Joined: 03 Feb 2009
Posts: 159
Rep Level: 4
Rep Points: 7
Rep Hits: 2


Location: Australia

Rep This Post
PostPosted: Mon Jun 29, 2009 6:38 pm

Post Number: 5517
Reply with quote Report

Presbyterian Deacon, Lynx, freshmao and Samuel,

Thank you all for your valuable input into the discussion. I have been doing a little following up on The World Council of Churches and it appears that the Churches of Christ in Australia are members as are many reformed churches.  What I read about the World Council of Churches I found to be disturbing in light of the their connection with Rome and the rhetoric of some of their leaders. But does this make the Churches of Christ not a true church of Christ?

By reformed standards they may be seen as 'progressive' because they are not a litugical church but in our country where the majority protestant denomination is the Australian Christian Churches (renamed Assemblies of God) the Church of Christ is considered to be conservative because they are cessationist, hold to elder government and do not allow women to be pastors, all of which the Uniting Church (formerly Methodist) and Anglicans do. I appreciate your advice on this topic.

Blessings,

Rhonda.
_________________
Rhonda
MSN Messenger
View user's profile Send private message
Presbyterian Deacon

Admin
Admin
User Online:


Joined: 03 Jan 2009
Posts: 1587
Rep Level: 5
Rep Points: 69
Rep Hits: 15


Location: Vernon, CT

Rep This Post
PostPosted: Tue Jun 30, 2009 5:59 am

Post Number: 5522
Reply with quote Report

Rhonda wrote:
Presbyterian Deacon, Lynx, freshmao and Samuel,

Thank you all for your valuable input into the discussion. I have been doing a little following up on The World Council of Churches and it appears that the Churches of Christ in Australia are members as are many reformed churches.  What I read about the World Council of Churches I found to be disturbing in light of the their connection with Rome and the rhetoric of some of their leaders. But does this make the Churches of Christ not a true church of Christ?


Rhonda:

Are you sure about that? There is also a "World Convention of Churches of Christ" which is NOT the same group as the World Council of Churches.

Quote:

The offices of the World Convention are located in Nashville, Tennessee. Australian Jeff Weston serves as Executive Director (General Secretary). In addition to planning the quadrennial gathering of the Stone-Campbell Movement, the day-to-day ministry of World Convention seeks to build fellowship, understanding, common purpose and efectiveness within the global family of churches known as Christian, Churches of Christ and Disciples of Christ. The Executive Director travels the world preaching, teaching, encouraging and mentoring Christians on behalf of World Convention. He also represents the Stone-Campbell Movement family at a number of international ecumenical/world communion meetings. The World Convention website has a number of features, including National Profiles of some of the nearly 180 countirs and nations where Stone-Campbell Movement Churches have or have had a presence. These are composed by National Profiles Editor, Clinton J. Holloway. In addition, Holloway also authored a history of the World Convention, Together in Christ, A History of the World Convention of Churches of Christ, 1930-2008.


-- Sterling

______________________________________________

Edit:

Okay, here is a list of the Church of Christ Australia affiliations.

Affiliations:
National Council of Churches in Australia
Melbourne College of Divinity
Sydney College of Divinity
World Convention of Churches of Christ

I see that the National Council of Churches in Australia
Quote:
is an ecumenical organisation bringing together a number of Australia's Christian Churches in dialogue and practical cooperation.

It works in collaboration with state ecumenical councils around Australia. It is an associate council of the World Council of Churches, a member of the Christian Conference of Asia and a partner of other national ecumenical bodies throughout the world. Christian World Service, the international humanitarian and development agency of the NCCA, works with communities in 22 countries across Africa, Asia, the Middle East and the Pacific...


Rhonda wrote:
But does this make the Churches of Christ not a true church of Christ?
No. I haven't found anything which indicates that the Campbellites have had to compromise their doctrinal possitions in order to join this humanitarian effort.

But, of course, this is only my opinion, whatever it might be worth.

I think, as long your church is not teaching baptismal regeneration as an official position, identifies itself as a "Church of Christ" (and not "The Christian Church" or "Disciples of Christ"), and preaches the gospel of salvation by grace through faith, you're probably okay where you are. Wink
_________________
Sterling A. Harmon, Jr.
Deacon
Presbyterian Church of Coventry (PCA)

Reformed Theology Institute
Owner/Admin




"No learning is commendable which is not dipped in the love of God." --John Calvin

"A dog barks when his master is attacked. I would be a coward if I saw that God's truth is attacked and yet would remain silent." --John Calvin
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Rhonda

Sustaining Member
Sustaining Member
User Online:


Joined: 03 Feb 2009
Posts: 159
Rep Level: 4
Rep Points: 7
Rep Hits: 2


Location: Australia

Rep This Post
PostPosted: Tue Jun 30, 2009 5:38 pm

Post Number: 5524
Reply with quote Report

Thanks Sterling for settling this issue for me.
Quote:
I think, as long your church is not teaching baptismal regeneration as an official position, identifies itself as a "Church of Christ" (and not "The Christian Church" or "Disciples of Christ"), and preaches the gospel of salvation by grace through faith, you're probably okay where you are.
My heart says amen.



_________________
Rhonda
MSN Messenger
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Reformed Theology Institute Forum Index » Cults, Apostasies, Heresies, Heterodoxies Page Previous  1, 2


 
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
Interesting RTI Poll

Poll Link

Who is "the seed" of the woman mentioned in Genesis 3:15
Abel 0
Jesus Christ 19
All mankind in general 6
Total Votes : 25


Popular Topics
What is Total Inerrency?
It seems like something Satan would do even if its crazy....
Writers of Scripture and Ancient Near East Cosmology- repost
Lordship Salvation
What is the Purpose of Scripture?
open theism ?
Chirst as a True Man or Not a True Man?
Misisonary, Evangelist, & Preacher: What is the Differen
The end will come when ...
sundoulos2005--Introducing self
Argument for Existence of God from the Existence of Evil
J.C. Ryle gives a reminder of what we need to preach
Paul Washer a False Prophet?
Biblical Typology
Question on Revelation 21:14
Reformation
Fellowship at RTI forums re: acceptable evangelical umbrella
Inerrancy Discussions: A Guideline for posting.
Writers of Scripture and Ancient Near East Cosmology
Am I the only one?

Main Menu
Home Page
Forums
How-To FAQs
Membership Central
Private Messages
Photo Gallery
Smilies
Bible Encyclopedia
Bible Tool

Items of Interest
Thread Closings
RTI Statement of Faith
RTI New Member Contest for 2010
Help RTI Grow
Advertisement Free
WELCOME NEW MEMBERS!
RTI 'How To' Answers to Frequently Asked Questions
RTI Standards of Conduct
Adopt a Smiley $$ Campaign
About RTI

RTI Course Topics
Incrementalist's Guide to the Basics of My Teaching NT Greek
All Things Are Better In Koine
New Forums Created
Testing Biblical Fonts
REL 300: Conformation to the Image of Christ
REL 125 Assignment 1 Responses (Nature of Evil)
REL 125 Introduction and Assignments
RTI Education Policies and Practices
RTI Courses

Top Posters
Ask Mr. Religion 1756
Presbyterian Deacon 1587
bodhisattva 738
Lyncx9 681
SolaGrazia 386
Lon 335
J&R 312
freshmao 303
J.D.Longmire 257
mossy 228
yvieraebrae 220
mmstroud 219
jd.morrison 198
Rhonda 159
Gord 148

 
 

RTI Users Online
Name Time Posts
bodhisattva 2 Sep 12:26 738
mossy 2 Sep 12:29 228
Redispenformed 2 Sep 13:07 80
SpurgeonFellow 2 Sep 12:59 1

Back to top



Bookmark and Share

phpBB skin developed by: John Olson
Powered by
phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group

Your donation supports the RTI ministry to keep this site free for all Members! Proverbs 11:24-25


ip-location

Optional full banner
Create your own free forum | Buy a domain to use with your forum

Welcome To RTI "Guest"! Enjoy Your Stay!